Categories
Outsourcing

Outsourcing work vs In-House Recruitment: Which Is Best for UK Accountants?

Summarize and analyze this article with:

As an accountancy practice grows, managing the delivery of work, controlling costs, and serving clients becomes increasing complex. Trade-offs between the quality of work, spending time with clients and achieving deadlines are necessary and often driven by the resources available on any given day. Eventually, accountants face a critical decision: should we recruit additional staff or outsource certain tasks?

Both options have their advantages, but choosing the right approach has a significant impact on operational efficiency, costs, and long-term profitability. In this blog we examine the reasons why outsourcing can be a better alternative to in-house recruitment.

Recruitment and Onboarding Costs

While larger accounting practices have access to HR professionals and expert advice, smaller practices often struggle to keep on top of their legal responsibilities when recruiting new people. The process is often undertaken by accountants who may have no experience at all of implementing an effective recruitment strategy or conducting a thorough interview. 

 

When a new employee joins a practice, they expect a clear pathway and support towards their career goals. This will often involve incurring the costs of professional qualifications, continuing professional development and other ad-hoc training. The administration of these and other tasks to support new staff will also need to be met.

 

Using an outsourced solution removes the burden of:

  • Interviewing and vetting candidates
  • Conducting performance reviews
  • Managing payroll, leave, and employee disputes.

Engaging a specialist agent to search for suitable candidates can be expensive, with fees of up to 25% of a new employee’s salary typical of the amounts charged for roles where demand is high. The internal cost of onboarding a new team member is often overlooked. 

 

Offshoring services offers ready-made solutions for accountants looking to increase capacity without breaking the bank. There are further benefits through accessing a ready-made pool of talent and expertise without the investment needed to manage a full-time resource.

Employment Costs

High salary expectations and other costs of employment place financial strain on accountants and the level of fees they are able to support. To mitigate these costs, accountants are looking carefully at their workforce plans and adjusting roles and responsibilities accordingly.

 

In-house staff are usually entitled to additional employment benefits, including automatic enrolment into a pension scheme with contributions from the employer, and paid holiday. Some employers offer wider benefits which can amount to more than 20% of the base salary paid to an employee. Other significant costs which cannot be avoided include training, time for continuous personal development, office space, and infrastructure costs such as IT equipment and software.

 

This is where outsourcing comes into play. By entering into a fixed contract, accountants can plan their future cash flows effectively and reduce overheads. This helps manage costs and protect profit margins.

Peaks of Work

The need to match resources to demand for services throughout the accounting cycle can be difficult, particularly where accountants rely on a small number of professionals to deliver work at peak times in the year. When accountants are stretched, routine tasks quickly become urgent. Deadlines get tighter, errors become more likely, and senior members of the team spend their time working through backlogs instead of focusing on the wider business.

 

Hiring temporary or permanent staff may seem like an obvious solution, but it comes with a price: recruitment costs, training time, variable quality, and compliance risks.

 

In contrast, outsourcing offers a reliable, flexible solution that allows accountants to quickly increase capacity without the overheads and administrative burden of new appointments. Outsourcing work enables accountants to stay agile, efficient, and competitive throughout the year.

Scalability

One of the biggest challenges for a growing accounting practice is balancing new client acquisition with existing workloads. Taking on more clients is positive, but only if the practice has expertise to deliver the work efficiently and maintain service standards.

 

Outsourcing work offers access to a pool of resources to help address peaks in work or remove backlogs. Accountants have flexibility to commission resources when they need them on an ad-hoc (pay as you go), half time equivalent or full-time equivalent basis. There is no need to enter into a long-term contract, and the risks of overstaffing are avoided.

 

Investment in new technologies such as cloud accounting and automation of tasks means smaller Practices can introduce outsourced partners into their day-to-day operations with the minimum of disruption. This allows accountants to scale and grow without taking on the additional risk and costs of direct employment.

Specialist Skills

Recruiting an individual with expertise across all accounting tasks can be difficult. A Practice may need support with bookkeeping, payroll, VAT, management accounts, year-end accounts, and tax return preparation. Building an internal team with all these capabilities is expensive with a heightened risk of service failure should an individual leave at short notice.

Using an offshore resource allows accountants to focus on adding value to the business, understanding client needs, and delivering better outcomes in terms of quality and turnaround times for work. It also enables accountants to:

  • Tap into expertise, especially in areas like digital bookkeeping, tax calculations, and accounts preparation
  • Fill skills gaps quickly without lengthy training periods.

Quality Control and Client Management

One concern an accountant may have about outsourcing is losing control over the quality of work and delivery. Clients trust their accountant to deliver work to them compliant with applicable tax and accounting rules and without any errors or omissions. Using an outsourced accountant does not mean control over these important matters is lost. A well-managed outsourcing arrangement should include:

  • Clearly defined responsibilities and deliverables
  • Agreed turnaround times and deadlines
  • Consistent review and quality-control processes
  • Secure systems for sharing client information
  • Regular communication between the onshore team and offshore accountants.

The onshore accountant retains responsibility to oversee delivery work and achievement of deadlines, exercising professional judgement, client advice and final sign-off where required. The right outsourcing partner should operate as an extension of the practice, rather than simply an external supplier.

In summary: Outsourcing vs In-House Recruitment

Consideration Outsourcing In-House
Recruitment and Onboarding Costs Low to zero upfront costs. High initial investment in recruitment, infrastructure, equipment, and training.
Employment Costs Fixed contract. Salaries and associated overheads variable.
Peaks of Work Resources can be adjusted based on demand for services. Fixed capacity.
Scalability Rapid response to growth. Time lag to implement.
Specialist Skills Access to a global talent pool at fixed rates. No need to invest in long-term talent development. High cost of attracting and retaining top talent, especially in specialised roles. Regional variations in availability of talent.
Quality Control and Client Management Agreed protocols and responsibilities. Direct internal supervision.

Calculate The Savings Available From Outsourcing

The team at Unison Globus UK have prepared a calculator to help accountants estimate the savings available by outsourcing work offshore. The calculator is available on our website, and a link is provided below.

The calculator is easy to use and requires basic information to be entered about the UK regional location of the onshore accountant and type of resource required offshore. The calculator draws on salary information published annually by UK recruitment companies and the full-time equivalent cost of a resource provided by Unison Globus UK.

 

Unison Globus UK customers have the flexibility to commission resources when they need them on an ad-hoc (pay as you go), half time equivalent or full-time equivalent basis. 

Want to find out more about outsourcing?

Unison Globus UK’s outsourced tax, accounting and payroll services are suitable for all client engagements – from sole traders and micro businesses to large companies. We provide a free trial of up to 10 hours of accountant time, with turnaround in 72 hours. If you’re looking to outsource services for the first time, increase margins, and help your clients, you can book a video call with one of our expert advisors or email us at [email protected].